Rules revision

In my defense, when I banned him, I didn't know what the link lead to. Heck, I don't even now. All I knew was that it was clearly not the URL that it was labeled with.

While I understand where you are coming from, that really isn't that great of a defense. You didn't even know what he had linked to, so you assumed it was something worth banning him for. At the very least, you should have asked him what he had linked to before banning him.

Then again, it's not my place to tell you how to enforce the rules. I'm probably overstepping my bounds. I disagree with what you did, however.