Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Think about it from JKR's point of view. Why have someone steal the horcrux and leave mysterious initials that leaves everyone speculating for a couple of years until HP7 comes out, to reveal that it was someone who's been dead for years and adds no type of new character to the story. Bit of an anti-climax.

Good point though, I'd forgotten the letter said they were long dead...me and my memory eh? Tch!

I'm gonna stick with my thoughts about it not being Regulus.

Now you cna see why I'm not a betting man though......we'll all finish HP7, look back on this thread, see I was horribly, horribly wrong and work out how much I owe people in bets that it wasn't Regulus.

What do you mean book 4 doesnt come out until nov.?


That book came out years ago, for me.

Yea, I suppose it would have to be Regalus. One thing JK seems to do is bring back seemingly unimportant characters, and give them a bigger part in the story, so there's a good chance it could be Regalus. Of course, she could simply introduce someone new. Since everyone is expecting it to be Regalus, I wouldn't be surprised if JK does bring in a new character. But JKR has always had the technique to fool and awe the ones who least expect it..... The thing she does is mention things in books that you don't pick up on until you've read what they are used

I've never read any of the books and I don't plan on it. That aside. All these things mentioned, I thought I should point out are attributes of a really good author. She's not the only one who does this. Lots a Stephen Kings(hes just the only one off the top of my head right now) books do. Even his books that don't relate to each other, somehow they do in tiny ways it's crazy. Anyways peace.

Well if someone has already posted this... I'm sorry but I can't read this entire thread.

Think back to book 5. Remember when they were cleaning out #12 Grim... place? They found a locket they couldn't open. but the problem is they threw it away. Remember Kreacher kept stealing things and keeping them safe??? He probably got the Horcrux

dude, he split his soul 7 times... just... wow.

I meant the film of Book 4. You asked when the next film was coming out, and I told you. Nov. 18th.

oh wow i wonder when its coming out here!

hopfully around the same time, no?

I think they're going for a world wide release date of 18th November. I don't know.

Check a couple of sites, it should tell you there.

http://harrypotter.warnerbros.com/go...ire/index.html

Well, I was right with November 2005 at least...

What in gods name has Ron done to his hair??

Nice dress.

The interesting thing about this film is that it's directed by a British director. The guy who did Azkaban was busy filming that when the filming for this one started. So we've finally got a British guy, directing a film about a book set somewhere in Britain written by a British woman.