I'd go

CoH or Enigma
Andy's Visage(cham) or CoA(ber cham)
HoZ (um)
Dracul's Grasp
Gore Riders
String of Ears or Verdungo's
2x BK rings or 1 BK and 1 Raven (switch a cham in helm for ber)
Mara's (Or Highlord's if you don't need the resists and aren't at deadly strike cap)

As for weapon, either

Ethereal Upgraded Headstriker (Zod)
Azurewrath (Ber)
Ethereal Death Cleaver (Zod)

Don't look at me, though. I've never played a Zealot. Something in there has to be right, though, just by sheer statistical ordering.

What is it they say about silence being golden?