What constitutes an RPG?

Not hard to follow what you saying... just annoying and a waste of time to read a post 20x longer than it should be. Tho I most likely have to read it because it might say something that would change my reply. You might state something I am going to say etc... understand my point?

You don't need to dumb what you say down for anyone... I just find no reason to be so complex and detailed on a fucking forum. I mean, if you were telling a story... go ahead.

!King_Amazon! I seen something like that coming lol. Did I spell coming right?

seen

Saw*

I'm tired of debating. Let's all eat pie and play D&D.

HEHE I love D&D, me and MarkiX play it a lot, he is right about how you can bend/break the rules and the game is unlimited. That is why I love playing it.

That's also why it's a role-playing game.

Yes it is, I totally agree on that... that is actually how I consider a game RPG or not. If the game has any D&D type stuff in it(like the 3 things you pointed out) then to me it is an RPG.