Well then why does everybody think the Patriots are better than the Colts if the Colts have the toughest schedule and they're still 5-0?

Look at the divisions they're in:

AFC EAST
NE 5-0
Bills 1-4
Jets 1-4
Dolphins 0-5

AFC SOUTH
Colts 5-0
Titans 3-1
Jaguars 3-1
Texans 3-2

That doesn't even seem comparable. The Colts are in the toughest division in football -- every single team has a winning record. Just thought I'd point that out!