Zelaron Gaming Forum

Zelaron Gaming Forum (http://zelaron.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Discussion (http://zelaron.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=182)
-   -   $50 for the Speed of Light (http://zelaron.com/forum/showthread.php?t=29084)

Chruser 2004-05-08 07:13 PM

$50 for the Speed of Light
 
What's the best method you can think of to measure the speed of light with tools that in combination may not exceed a price tag of $50? I figured that a flashlight, ruler and a stopwatch would not be accurate enough, so go ahead and give it your best shot. :)

iceman887 2004-05-08 07:17 PM

is there a correct ansewr or like kinda possible way? im not smart enough

Jamesadin 2004-05-08 07:20 PM

Measure the distance from the sun to Earth, and measure how long it takes the light to get there....Though I don't really know how you could measure that. o_O

kaos 2004-05-08 07:27 PM

So if you answer correctly, you get $50?

iceman887 2004-05-08 07:29 PM

no.... u have think of a way to measure the speed of light by using tools that cost a total of less than 50 dollars, didn't u read what chruser said?

Chruser 2004-05-08 07:30 PM

Well, you could use a radar to send light impulses that hit the target and then return to the point of origin, and then the time taken divided by two, along with the known distance can easily give you the speed of light. Radars aren't really that cheap though as far as I know. And measuring large distances with triangulation gets kind of messy without some half-decent options and measurement tools. I'd be impressed by a solution which doesn't have any known values as a base, such as the distance to the moon or Sol from Earth.

And iceman, this is an experimental question.

Grav 2004-05-08 07:35 PM

Simple.

Twenty random people that pay for the www.penny-arcade.com forums.

Promise them doritos and mountain dew ($30), lure them into a room.

Insert naked woman. ($20)

The time it takes them all to smash into the woman at the same time should be approximately 1/2 the speed of light.

Insanity 2004-05-08 08:29 PM

Physics is a pain in the ass, but here goes.

Nothing travels faster than light - it only takes 8 minutes for it to reach the Earth from the nearest star, the Sun, which is 150 million kilometers away. This means that when you see the sun (remember not look directly at the sun), you’re really seeing light that left the sun 8 minutes ago – you’re seeing the sun as it was, and where it was, 8 minutes earlier.
One of the first to try to measure the speed of light was Galileo: In the early 17th century, the general belief amongst scientists (or natural philosophers as they were often called then) was that the speed of light was infinite; that is, light could travel any distance in no time at all. Just as with many other important discoveries made by Galileo, he disagreed with most of his contemporaries. One of Galileo’s great strengths as a scientist was his ability to conceive experiments to test his theories.

To measure the speed of light, he and his assistant each took a shuttered lantern to hilltops one mile apart. Galileo flashed his lantern, and the assistant was supposed to open the shutter to his own lantern as soon as he saw Galileo's light. Galileo would then time how long it took before he saw the light from the other hilltop. Then, he could divide the distance by the time he measured to get a speed.
Unfortunately for Galileo, this time he had not conceived an experiment sufficiently clever to measure the extraordinary speed with which light traveled. We now know that light travels at approximately 3x108 m/s (that is approximately 1100000000 km/Hr), so it would travel the one mile (1.6 km) between the hills in 0.000005 s (5 microseconds), whereas, even if Galileo could time such a short trip, the assistant could not possibly unshutter his lantern fast enough that Galileo could tell what part of his measurement was the travel time!

In fact, due to the extraordinarily high value of c (c is the standard symbol physicists use for the speed of light), there was no where on earth any two people could stand so that they could conduct this experiment. In order to make such a direct measurement of the speed of light, one needed a laboratory much larger than the earth! Remarkably, Galileo had effectively created such a Laboratory with another of his discoveries – the moons of Jupiter.

In the 1676, Danish Astronomer Ole Roemer made the first reasonable observation of the finite speed of light. Since Galileo’s discovery of the larger Jovian moons, a great deal of telescopic observation lead to extremely precise measurements of the orbital period of Io (1.76 Days). Testing these calculations, Roemer observed the eclipses over the course of a Jovian year. Roemer found that as Jupiter moved further from the Earth, his predictions of when Jupiter’s moons would cross its face became less and less accurate. The times that he saw Io cross the face of Jupiter became steadily later than the times predicted, as much as one and a quarter hours late. However, as he continued to observe, he was able to discount the idea that his predictions were simply wrong, as on its approach to the earth, the events once again approached his predicted times. In a stroke of genius, Roemer attributed this discrepancy to the finite speed of light, and he even published an estimate of that speed, approximately two thirds the currently accepted value (due to the inaccurate estimates of the size of Earth and Jupiter’s orbits of his contemporaries). With the correct measurements of the orbits, Roemer’s data gives a speed of light equal to 3x108 m/s.

In an unwitting homage to Roemer, the motion of Jupiter now seems to have allowed measurement of the speed gravity propagates.

Nothing travels faster than light - it only takes 8 minutes for it to reach the Earth from the nearest star, the Sun, which is 150 million kilometers away. This means that when you see the sun (remember not look directly at the sun), you’re really seeing light that left the sun 8 minutes ago – you’re seeing the sun as it was, and where it was, 8 minutes earlier.
One of the first to try to measure the speed of light was Galileo: In the early 17th century, the general belief amongst scientists (or natural philosophers as they were often called then) was that the speed of light was infinite; that is, light could travel any distance in no time at all. Just as with many other important discoveries made by Galileo, he disagreed with most of his contemporaries. One of Galileo’s great strengths as a scientist was his ability to conceive experiments to test his theories.

To measure the speed of light, he and his assistant each took a shuttered lantern to hilltops one mile apart. Galileo flashed his lantern, and the assistant was supposed to open the shutter to his own lantern as soon as he saw Galileo's light. Galileo would then time how long it took before he saw the light from the other hilltop. Then, he could divide the distance by the time he measured to get a speed.
Unfortunately for Galileo, this time he had not conceived an experiment sufficiently clever to measure the extraordinary speed with which light traveled. We now know that light travels at approximately 3x108 m/s (that is approximately 1100000000 km/Hr), so it would travel the one mile (1.6 km) between the hills in 0.000005 s (5 microseconds), whereas, even if Galileo could time such a short trip, the assistant could not possibly unshutter his lantern fast enough that Galileo could tell what part of his measurement was the travel time!

In fact, due to the extraordinarily high value of c (c is the standard symbol physicists use for the speed of light), there was no where on earth any two people could stand so that they could conduct this experiment. In order to make such a direct measurement of the speed of light, one needed a laboratory much larger than the earth! Remarkably, Galileo had effectively created such a Laboratory with another of his discoveries – the moons of Jupiter.

In the 1676, Danish Astronomer Ole Roemer made the first reasonable observation of the finite speed of light. Since Galileo’s discovery of the larger Jovian moons, a great deal of telescopic observation lead to extremely precise measurements of the orbital period of Io (1.76 Days). Testing these calculations, Roemer observed the eclipses over the course of a Jovian year. Roemer found that as Jupiter moved further from the Earth, his predictions of when Jupiter’s moons would cross its face became less and less accurate. The times that he saw Io cross the face of Jupiter became steadily later than the times predicted, as much as one and a quarter hours late. However, as he continued to observe, he was able to discount the idea that his predictions were simply wrong, as on its approach to the earth, the events once again approached his predicted times. In a stroke of genius, Roemer attributed this discrepancy to the finite speed of light, and he even published an estimate of that speed, approximately two thirds the currently accepted value (due to the inaccurate estimates of the size of Earth and Jupiter’s orbits of his contemporaries). With the correct measurements of the orbits, Roemer’s data gives a speed of light equal to 3x108 m/s.

In an unwitting homage to Roemer, the motion of Jupiter now seems to have allowed measurement of the speed gravity propagates.

When you turn on your microwave oven, electrical circuits inside start generating microwaves – electromagnetic waves with frequencies (which we'll call "f" later) around 2.5 gigahertz – 2500000000 Hz. These waves bounce back and forth between the walls of the oven, the size of which is chosen so that the peaks and troughs of the reflected waves line up with the incoming waves and form a “standing wave”.

If you pluck a guitar string, you’ll set it vibrating. Usually, you will excite the “first harmonic” – a standing wave that has the string stationary at the bridge and the fret, and vibrating back and forth in the center. With effort, you might be able to excite the second harmonic (try plucking the string in opposite directions ¼ of the way in from either end), then you’ll see the string vibrating back and forth, with the center stationary.

This pattern has three nodes or points with no displacement away from rest (there’s a useful mnemonic - a NODe has NO Displacement): the ends and the center, and two anti-nodes: ¼ and ¾ of the way along its length. There are infinitely many modes, one for each positive integer, with more and more nodes between the fret and the bridge.
A full wave is shaped like a “sine function” going from zero to a maximum back through zero to a negative maximum and back to zero again - like the second harmonic in the figure on this page. So you can see that the distance between the maximum displacements of the wave is one half the wavelength.

The electromagnetic field inside the microwave behaves in roughly the same way – except the vibrations are in “the electromagnetic field”. Where the vibrations are greatest (the anti nodes), you will see the greatest heating, but at the nodes, the chocolate will only melt slowly as heat diffuses into those areas.

Thus, the distance between the melted regions (x) is equal to the distance between the antinodes, and equal to half the wavelength (λ)!

So, the detailed calculation to find the speed of light (c) is:


c=λ*f
c=2*x*f

Ever eager to confirm things for himself, your guide conducted this experiment in his kitchen. In order to protect my microwave, I took the probably unnecessary (but I would recommend doing this to everyone) precaution of placing a half glass of water in the microwave – if there is insufficient material in a microwave, you can blow the internal fuses, rendering the microwave inoperable. However, as the microwave then had to heat the water as well, the melting process took almost two minutes, rather than twenty seconds.
Once I took the chocolate out of the microwave (not have access to Milky Way Stars, I used a block of Ghirardelli semisweet chocolate – a solid block of chocolate conducts heat along its length more than a collection of small chocolates, so I would recommend using some sort of chocolate chips when you do this your self) I measured the distance between the melted points from my sample was 6cm.

As my microwave didn’t have a frequency reading on the back, I will use the 2.5GHz “typical” value I found after a brief web search.

Thus: the wavelength is .06m x 2 = 0.12m Then the speed is 0.12m x 2.5 x 109 /s = 3 x 108 m/s, which is a pretty good estimate! If you want to do better, you can try repeating the measurement many times (and making very accurate measurements) and applying statistics to get an average, and an estimate of how much uncertainty you have.

Pablo Coronel, of the Food Science Department at North Carolina State University, has sent me a few more suggestions like this one:

Marshmallows, they swell when heated in the Mico-Wave oven, so it can be fun.
2. Fax paper, the thermal type, place a piece of cardboard and a wet (but not soaked) paper towel beneath the fax paper. There will be dark spots where the antinodes are.

Another reader also recalled having, as a microwave technician, tested the wavelength of microwaves using a small bulb and a short piece of wire connecting the bulb's terminals. If the wire is at a node, then there will be no current in the wire and the bulb will not glow. However, if the bulb is away from the nodes and is aligned parallel to the direction of the electromagnetic field at that point, the field will cause a current to flow in the wire, lighting the bulb. The bulb will light brightest at the anti-node. However, I do not recommend trying this at home, as metal objects should not be placed in the microwave.

kaos 2004-05-08 08:57 PM

I say you get a flashlight, then get a ruler. Turn on the flashlight and measure the light.

GIMEM %) DOLLARS1

Insanity 2004-05-08 09:42 PM

Don't waste space dorky

Arkantis 2004-05-08 09:52 PM

But no serously, I would bye a some kind of material that just fell to waste in light, so I could mesure the exact distance from the material, and then from the light, when it falls apart it stops, but I dont think that is possible.

iceman887 2004-05-08 09:55 PM

u repeated like 4 paragraphs, why did u do that? and btw did u type all that

Adrenachrome 2004-05-08 09:55 PM

A laser a mirror and laser activated stopwatch should handle it.

Titusfied 2004-05-09 08:10 AM

Just a side fact from reading this post, which I thought was pretty interesting:

Super novas are a phenaomena that occur very rarely. Basically, when a star implodes, as the Sun eventually will do, just not in our lifetimes, or in the next many many many generations, it lets off a large source of light, called a nova. Super novas are a little different. This is when a star implodes twice, and the second implosion lets off an extremely large amount of light from the ridiculous amount of energy released.

The last super nova seen lit up the night sky for many seconds, which is an amazing feat. It has been studied that when we usually see super nova light flashes, which only occur once in a lifetime if you are lucky, it is the product of star that imploded millions of years ago.

Basically saying, that stars are very far away, with retrospect to the 8 second factoid presented by Insanity above.

Medieval Bob 2004-05-09 09:20 AM

Too bad you pasted the first part of that post twice...

Randuin 2004-05-09 11:09 AM

Thank you for posting something we already knew, he wants an alternative CHEAP way to measure it.

Insanity 2004-05-09 11:17 AM

i must of messed it up when I edited it, my bad :-\

Hades-Knight 2004-05-09 11:43 AM

Hmm so if light from the sun takes 8 minutes to reach earth, that means your seeing the sun as it was 8 minutes ago......... what if you went to the sun and watched the earth.....you would be looking into the past by 8 minutes right? what if you went farther away you'd be looking into the past!!

!King_Amazon! 2004-05-09 12:51 PM

Shit, I thought you were gonna give someone $50 to tell you the speed of light, which everyone knows is 3x10^8.

Insanity 2004-05-09 01:46 PM

he wants a cheap way to measure it.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:20 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
This site is best seen with your eyes open.